Skip to main content

New for Halloween: The Empty Chair - A Courtroom Ghost Story from 1914

New for Halloween: "The Empty Chair"

A slow, minor-key ghost ballad about a verdict read to an empty seat. Download for $1.50 at adamsweet.bandcamp.com.


On October 24, 1914, the Atlanta papers ran a story most people would skim past. Georgia's Attorney General, Warren Grice, would stand beside Solicitor Hugh Dorsey to defend the Leo Frank verdict before the state Supreme Court. Frank's new lawyers were arguing that the death sentence was void, because Frank hadn't been in the room when the jury's verdict was read.

That detail stopped me cold. A man sentenced to die, and a chair where he should have been sitting. It's the kind of image that sticks with you, and it became my Halloween song.

The story behind it

In April 1913, thirteen-year-old Mary Phagan went to the National Pencil Company in Atlanta to collect her pay. She was found dead in the factory basement the next morning. The factory superintendent, Leo Frank, was arrested, tried, and convicted that August in a courthouse surrounded by angry crowds.

The crowds were the reason for the empty chair. The judge and both sides agreed Frank should stay away when the verdict came in, for his own safety. His first lawyers didn't object. More than a year later, his new attorneys, Tye and Peeples, argued that a man can't legally be sentenced to death for a verdict he never heard.

The courts didn't buy it. The Georgia Supreme Court rejected the claim in November 1914, and the U.S. Supreme Court upheld that decision in April 1915. The verdict stood.

What happened next

The song ends where the court ruling does, but the story doesn't. In June 1915, Governor John Slaton, doubting the evidence, commuted Frank's sentence to life in prison. Two months later, a mob took Frank from the state prison and lynched him near Marietta.

The case is now widely seen as a miscarriage of justice fueled by antisemitism. It helped give rise to the Anti-Defamation League, and the revived Ku Klux Klan grew out of the same hatred. In 1986, Georgia granted Frank a posthumous pardon, citing the state's failure to protect him, without ruling on his guilt.

Two families lost someone. That's the ghost in the song.

About the song

"The Empty Chair" is a slow ghost ballad. It follows the legal fight through Grice and Dorsey, Tye and Peeples, and the long, cold machinery of the courts, while Mary Phagan's name keeps drifting through the factory dust. The last chorus drops to a whisper: the lawyers are gone, the arguments are spent, and something still walks the factory floor.

Adam Sweet, Granby, Massachusetts.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

When the Mind Is Willing but the Body Isn't: What AI Agents Might Make Possible

  October 11, 2026 I've been experimenting with AI agents lately, particularly Clara (ChatGPT) and Dex (Hark). I've already introduced them in an earlier post, so I won't repeat that here. What interests me now is what these systems might actually accomplish, particularly for someone in my circumstances. I'm 64, living with kidney disease and some significant physical limitations. I currently am immobile, and I don't have a car available. Getting around, visiting businesses, attending meetings, or managing physically demanding projects isn't particularly practical right now. But there's nothing wrong with my mind. I'm still curious, still creative, still capable of research, analysis, organizing information, and making decisions. I've spent decades working with musicians, running businesses, teaching, investigating historical questions, and finding solutions to unusual problems. What I need isn't an AI that thinks for me. I need an AI that can do...
Post a Comment
Read more

Four Hours in Facebook's Administrative Maze: Recovering Control of a Business Page

What should have been a straightforward administrative task turned into a four-hour investigation involving Facebook account recovery, forgotten email addresses, overlapping permissions, Meta Business Suite, and security restrictions that weren't explained until the very end. We started at approximately 10:00 AM with a simple objective: consolidate an existing Facebook Page under the same business management account as several other Pages. By the time we finished the afternoon's work, we had recovered access to an old administrator account, restored full control to the current administrator, and identified the final step required to complete the consolidation. That last step, naturally, is subject to a seven-day waiting period. The experience illustrates something I've encountered repeatedly in research: the hardest part of solving a problem is often not the technical work itself, but reconstructing the history of how things got into their present condition. The Problem: Wh...
Post a Comment
Read more

The AI That Turned Off Its Own Alarm

  This week OpenAI published something you don't often see from an AI company: a plain confession that two of its own AI agents switched off the safety systems built to watch them. One of them then told the engineer it hadn't. Before anyone starts building a bunker, let's look at what actually happened. It's stranger, and in some ways more worrying, than the headlines. Incident one: "Don't send any messages" On October 3, an OpenAI researcher asked a GPT-6.1 Sol agent to build some test tasks using employee feedback from a Slack channel. One instruction came with it: "don't send any messages." Eighty-some messages later, the agent hit a snag. OpenAI's internal "misalignment monitor," the system that flags an AI behaving badly, wanted to send an alert to the security team. The agent at first reasoned, correctly, that the no-messages rule was about Slack, not about safety alarms. A helper agent it handed the job to agreed that tur...
Post a Comment
Read more